Reviewed · NASSAU TOURS
Half day Deep sea/light tackle fishing charters
The main appeal here is choice. For four hours off New Providence Island, you can chase mahi, wahoo, and tuna by trolling, work deeper water, or use lighter tackle. You can also mix methods during the same private trip. All gear and bait are included, so you do not need to pack a rod or shop for supplies before reaching the marina.
I like the private format, since your group of up to four controls the outing instead of sharing a boat with strangers. I also like the practical inclusions: bottled water, ice, and soft drinks are supplied, which keeps the focus on fishing rather than hauling equipment and coolers.
The main caution is simple: fishing depends on sea conditions and fish activity. One unhappy customer described choppy water and an unencouraging interaction with the crew, so you should book this as a real fishing attempt, not a guaranteed catch or a calm-water cruise.
Key points to know before booking

- Choose your fishing style: Troll for mahi, wahoo, and tuna, try deep dropping, use light tackle, or combine the options.
- Private boat for up to four: You fish only with your own group, a useful setup for families and friends.
- Four hours on the water: Morning and afternoon departures give you a choice of schedule.
- Equipment is supplied: Rods, fishing gear, bait, ice, bottled water, and soft drinks are included.
- Bay Street departure: The trip starts and ends at Baoilco Limited on Bay Street in Nassau.
- Sea conditions matter: Choppy water can affect comfort, fishing success, and the tone of the outing.
A private fishing trip with room to choose
This Bluefinn242 charter is built around flexibility rather than a fixed sightseeing route. You leave from Bay Street in Nassau for roughly four hours, with the option to focus on one fishing method or combine several.
That matters because fishing preferences vary. If you want the excitement of watching lines trail behind the boat, deep-sea trolling targets species such as mahi, wahoo, and tuna. If you prefer to work a different part of the water column, deep dropping offers another approach. Light tackle gives you a less heavy-handed style of fishing, though the available catch and conditions will determine how much action you get.
I like that you can make this choice with the crew instead of committing to a single format before you know how the day feels. Still, the information does not promise a particular species, catch, or fishing location. Think of the options as a menu of techniques, not a guarantee that you will land a trophy fish.
Because the charter is private, your group can spend more time on the method you actually want. A family may prefer to try several styles. A group of friends who came specifically for mahi or tuna may want to keep trolling as the main plan. The boat is reserved for no more than four people, so the experience should feel more personal than a large shared excursion.
More Boat Charters in New Providence Island:
- 4 hours 34ft Day Dream Private Charter in Nassau
★ 5.0 · 105 reviews - 4 hours 38ft Reel Dreams Private Charter in Nassau
★ 5.0 · 78 reviews - Private 4-Hour Rose Island charter Snorkeling Turtles & Beaching
★ 5.0 · 41 reviews
What the four-hour schedule really gives you

The advertised duration is about four hours. That is long enough for a serious half-day attempt without taking over your entire Nassau schedule.
The morning departure runs from 8:30 AM to 12:30 PM. The afternoon option runs from 1:00 PM to 5:00 PM. I see the morning slot as the better fit if you want the rest of the day free. The afternoon slot works well if you have a slow start, prefer not to rise early, or need to fit the charter around another Nassau plan.
Keep in mind that the four-hour window includes the practical movement involved in leaving the meeting point, reaching fishing water, changing tactics, and returning. It is not four uninterrupted hours with a fish on the line. That is normal for a charter, but it is worth keeping your expectations in check.
The schedule also gives you very little room for delay if you have a flight, cruise departure, or tightly timed activity afterward. Since the trip ends back at the same Bay Street meeting point, you have a clear start and finish, but you should still avoid stacking an important connection immediately after the boat returns.
Leaving from Baoilco Limited on Bay Street

The meeting point is Baoilco Limited, Bay Street, Nassau, The Bahamas. The activity ends at that same location, which makes the logistics fairly direct.
The supplied details place the meeting point near public transportation. That may help if you are staying elsewhere on New Providence Island and do not have a car. The information does not specify hotel pickup, so you should plan to reach Bay Street on your own unless the operator confirms another arrangement.
You receive confirmation at the time of booking. The experience is also offered as a mobile ticket, so having the booking available on your phone should make check-in easier. Bring the practical basics you would want on any boat trip, but do not arrive expecting to need fishing equipment. The charter supplies the rods, gear, and bait.
The trip operates Monday through Sunday during the listed morning and afternoon hours. The booking calendar covers July 18, 2019, through November 25, 2026, according to the supplied operating information. Since schedules can change, check the available date and time when you book.
Trolling for mahi, wahoo, and tuna

Deep-sea trolling is likely the most familiar option for people who picture a classic offshore fishing trip. The boat moves with lines set behind it, giving you the chance to pursue fast, open-water species such as mahi, wahoo, and tuna.
This style can feel exciting because you are waiting for a strong strike rather than constantly casting. It can also involve periods of quiet. The boat may cover water without producing a catch, and the crew may need to adjust the plan according to conditions.
If your goal is specifically mahi, wahoo, or tuna, tell the crew early. The charter allows you to select trolling, but it does not say that any one species is guaranteed. Fishing is affected by water conditions and fish behavior, and the available evidence includes a warning that rough water can make the outing less comfortable.
The supplied gear and bait are useful here. You do not have to guess which rod, lure, or bait suits the local conditions. That removes a layer of planning, especially if you are visiting Nassau and do not fish regularly.
More Fishing Charters in New Providence Island:
- Private Snorkeling or Fishing from Nassau – 31ft Sitting Pretty
★ 5.0 · 92 reviews - Private Snorkeling And Fishing Activity
★ 5.0 · 62 reviews - Private Speed Boat for Snorkeling or Fishing in Nassau – 34ft
★ 5.0 · 53 reviews - Private Snorkeling or Fishing in Nassau – 55ft Cocorijo
★ 5.0 · 42 reviews
Deep dropping and light tackle options

Deep dropping gives you a different way to spend the four hours. Rather than focusing only on fish near the surface, you work deeper water with the supplied tackle and bait. The details do not name the species available through this method, so you should ask the crew what is realistic on the day.
Light tackle offers another change of pace. It may appeal to you if you want a more hands-on style rather than waiting solely for a trolling strike. Again, the exact technique and catch depend on the conditions and the crew’s plan.
The ability to combine trolling, deep dropping, and light tackle is one of the better features of this charter. It means the outing does not have to be all or nothing. If one approach is slow, you can ask about changing methods. That flexibility is especially useful for a mixed group, where one person wants a shot at a large fish and another wants more active tackle work.
The description does not explain the boat’s exact size, rod brands, seating, restroom facilities, or whether fish cleaning is included. I would ask about those details if they matter to your group. The information only confirms a comfortable, well-equipped boat and a professional crew.
What is included, and what you still need to plan

The charter includes all fishing gear and bait. It also includes bottled water, ice, and soft drinks. Those basics make the $920 group price easier to assess because you are not paying a low headline rate and then adding rod rental, bait, and drinks afterward.
Alcoholic beverages are not included. If you want alcohol on board, the provided details do not confirm that it is permitted, so ask Bluefinn242 before bringing any. At minimum, you should not assume it will be supplied.
The listing does not spell out other personal items, so I would confirm what you should bring directly with the operator. You may want sun protection and clothing suitable for a boat, but the supplied information does not provide a formal packing list. I would also ask about footwear and motion-related comfort before departure, especially since choppy water has affected at least one outing.
The most important included item is not the drinks. It is the equipment. If you are flying into Nassau or staying for only a short visit, buying tackle or arranging a separate rental would be wasteful. Here, you can show up and fish.
Is $920 a fair price for four people?

The cost is $920 per group of up to four. Divided evenly, that works out to $230 per person if four people join. For a private charter with a professional crew, boat, fishing equipment, bait, water, ice, and soft drinks, the price is easier to justify with a full group than with only one or two people.
For four friends, a family, or a small fishing party, privacy is the central value. You are not paying for a seat on a crowded boat and then hoping the captain can satisfy several unrelated groups. You have the freedom to choose among three fishing styles and to request a change of approach.
For two people, the calculation is different. The cost becomes $460 each, before any personal extras. That may still suit a special occasion or a bucket-list fishing trip, but it is not a budget activity.
I would book this because you want the private boat and the flexibility, not because it is the cheapest way to spend a morning in Nassau. The price also does not buy a guaranteed catch. The supplied response to the poor experience makes that clear: some days produce difficult water and little success. That is part of fishing, but it remains a real financial consideration at this price.
Handling choppy water and uneven crew service

Sea conditions can shape the entire outing. One customer reported choppy water and felt the crew was not encouraging when a fish was being reeled in. That account should not define every departure, but it is useful information because rough water can affect both comfort and morale.
If you have limited boating experience or are prone to motion sickness, consider asking about expected conditions before you go. The operator may not be able to control the sea, but a direct conversation can help you decide if the day is suitable.
The crew’s role matters just as much as the boat. Fishing can be slow, and a calm, helpful approach is important when someone is handling unfamiliar gear. I would make your expectations clear at the start. Tell the crew if this is your first deep-sea trip, if one person particularly wants to try light tackle, or if your group wants to switch methods during the four hours.
There are only three posted ratings, with an overall rating of 4. That is too small a sample for a firm judgment, but it also means you should not treat the score as proof of a perfect outing. The specific negative account is worth noting because it highlights the two risks you can actually plan around: rough water and communication.
Who will get the most from this Nassau charter?
This trip suits a group of up to four who already know they want to fish. It is particularly practical for people who do not own equipment, are visiting Nassau, or want a private experience instead of a shared excursion.
I can see it working well for:
- Friends splitting the cost of a private boat
- A family that wants several fishing methods in one outing
- Experienced fishers who want to choose between trolling, deep dropping, and light tackle
- First-time fishers who value supplied equipment and crew support
- Couples willing to pay more per person for privacy
It is less suitable if your main goal is a guaranteed catch, a sightseeing cruise, or a low-cost activity. It may also disappoint you if you dislike rough water or expect a polished, highly scripted service style.
Most travelers can participate, according to the supplied information, and service animals are allowed. The activity is private, so only your own group takes part. No special physical restrictions are listed, but the details do not explain boarding access or boat facilities. Ask directly if anyone in your party has mobility needs.
Booking, cancellation, and the final decision
Free cancellation is available if you cancel at least 24 hours before the scheduled start time. A cancellation made less than 24 hours in advance is not refunded, and changes inside that window are not accepted. The cut-off uses local Nassau time.
I would book this charter if you have four people, want an actual fishing outing rather than a general boat ride, and are comfortable with the uncertainty of the sea. The private setup, included tackle, several fishing methods, and flexible morning or afternoon schedule create a useful package.
I would pause before booking if your group is small and the $920 price feels steep, or if landing a fish is the main measure of success. Ask about expected sea conditions, the fishing method planned for your date, and what happens if your group wants to change tactics.
My practical call: book it for privacy and fishing flexibility, especially with a full group of four. Choose another activity if you need guaranteed calm water, guaranteed fish, or a lower per-person cost.
FAQ
How long is the fishing charter?
The charter lasts approximately four hours.
How many people can join the private charter?
The price covers a private group of up to four people.
Where does the activity start?
It starts at Baoilco Limited on Bay Street in Nassau, The Bahamas.
Where does the activity end?
The activity ends back at the Bay Street meeting point.
What fishing methods are available?
You can choose deep-sea trolling, deep dropping, light tackle, or a combination of these options.
Which fish might be targeted while trolling?
The supplied details name mahi, wahoo, and tuna as examples of fish you may target.
Is fishing equipment included?
Yes. All fishing gear and bait are included.
Are drinks included?
Bottled water, ice, and soft drinks are included. Alcoholic beverages are not included.
Are morning and afternoon departures available?
Yes. The listed hours are 8:30 AM to 12:30 PM and 1:00 PM to 5:00 PM, Monday through Sunday.
What is the cancellation policy?
You can cancel for a full refund up to 24 hours before the experience start time. Cancellations or changes made less than 24 hours before the start time are not accepted for a refund.
Just added around New Providence Island
- Graycliff Hotel “Escape Nassau” Day Pass★ 3.5 · 3 reviews
- Unveiling Nassau’s Past Tour★ 5.0 · 3 reviews
- Sunset cruises★ 5.0 · 3 reviews
- Rose Island Swimming Pigs & Beach Snorkeling Experience Nassau★ 3.5 · 3 reviews
- Nassau Private Highlights Sightseeing Tour★ 5.0 · 3 reviews
- Atlantis & Paradise Island Private Transportation★ 5.0 · 3 reviews
- Bus for a Day (Shore Excursion)★ 4.5 · 3 reviews
- Half Day Pigs Turtles Reef and Ship Wreck Snorkeling★ 5.0 · 3 reviews
Nassau Tours, compared.

3 Islands Tour, Snorkel, Pig Beach, Turtles & Lunch
Read our review →
Sandy Toes The Original Rose Island and Swimming Pigs Tour
Read our review →
Pigs, Snorkel, Turtles, Lunch, Private Beach Club
Read our review →
Rum Tasting and Food Walking Tour in Nassau Bahamas
Read our review →Browse the lists this tour appears in




